A famous tolerance argument
He reflects on an observation he once read, attributed to David Friend of ARP: there is more variation in sound from one synth to another of the same model than between a Minimoog and an ARP Odyssey. The reason, he says, is that most resistors of the time had 5 percent tolerance, accumulating through the system, and early-1970s integrated circuits varied in performance and longevity.
He adds a quote from Rick Wakeman, who owned perhaps ten Minimoogs and said each sounded different. His conclusion is that it is possible to make a System 55 sound extremely close to a vintage Minimoog.
In the System 55 vs Minimoog comparison, price and playability matter as much as raw sound.
The oscilloscope differences
His final test strips the signal down to a single sawtooth through the entire signal path, with mixer levels at maximum, filter cutoff at maximum and resonance off. On the oscilloscope he notes three differences. First, the System 55 waveform is the most symmetrical around the ground line, whereas the Minimoog’s seems to have an offset and does not go as far in the negative direction.
Second, both waveforms reset to the high level almost instantly, though this excursion takes noticeably longer as the cutoff is lowered. Third, the Minimoog’s sawtooth does not slope in a straight line from top to bottom, whereas the System 55’s does. He does not know whether this is audible, or why the slope angle differs.
System 55 vs Minimoog: which one makes more sense?
His answer to the question he posed is yes: the System 55 can sound very close to a Minimoog, and any differences are of the same order as those between two vintage units. If you want an authentic original with its individual quirks, the 1977 Minimoog is the real thing. If you want the Moog sound in a modular format at a far lower cost, he finds the System 55 convincing.
That is the System 55 vs Minimoog decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.
Related comparisons
Sources