The Poly D as a hot-rodded Minimoog
The Behringer Poly D, he explains, follows the company’s Model D, which replicated the Minimoog circuitry closely, including the filters. The Poly D then extends the idea: it adds an oscillator, chorus and distortion, an arpeggiator and a sequencer, none of which exist on the original. The chorus, in his description, is based on a Juno-60 chip.
He is clear about what he hears when he plays it: it is so close that it is difficult for him to say the original is a good investment from a musical point of view.
In the Minimoog vs Poly D comparison, price and playability matter as much as raw sound.
Investment versus music
His position splits the question in two. As a collector’s item, he does not think the Minimoog is a bad investment. Only 10,000 to 12,000 units exist, many are in disrepair, and values appear stable and even growing. He also points to the intangible side: the smell of old circuitry and wood, the bigger scale and the aura of a vintage instrument.
As a musical tool, he comes down on the side of newer instruments. He mentions Roland’s modeling technology with an “age” parameter as a sign that aging changes tone, but wonders whether that change is fine wine or sour wine. For four or five thousand dollars, he argues, you may be better off with a replica or a newer Moog product that adds USB, MIDI, an arpeggiator and a sequencer.
The Minimoog vs Poly D question rarely has a single right answer, because it depends on how you actually work.
Minimoog vs Poly D: which one makes more sense?
For him, the Minimoog is a trophy piece for the studio wall, and the Poly D or another modern Moog is the better musical choice. The decision, as he says himself, is one only you can make. But the framing is valuable: whether you are buying history or sound is the real question.
That is the Minimoog vs Poly D decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.
Related comparisons
Sources