Home›Reviews›Behringer Model D vs Moog Minimoog Model D: Is the name…
Reviews

Behringer Model D vs Moog Minimoog Model D: Is the name worth the premium?

Model D vs Minimoog Model D: how do they really differ? We break down sound, controls and value from Noir Et Blanc Vie’s hands-on video test to help you choose.

Bernardo de Azevedo
Bernardo de Azevedo
· Updated
Behringer Model D vs Moog Minimoog Model D comparison

Choosing between the Behringer Model D and the Minimoog Model D? This Model D vs Minimoog Model D comparison summarizes what Noir Et Blanc Vie found when testing both instruments, so you can see how they differ in sound, controls and value before you buy.

Few comparisons divide synth players as reliably as the Behringer Model D against the Moog Minimoog Model D. One side sees a $300 synth that makes a legendary sound accessible. The other sees a hand-built instrument whose value goes beyond its circuitry. The most interesting take on this debate is one that changes sides in public: a reviewer returns to the video he calls his most hated and concedes that he was wrong about the Behringer.

That makes the argument unusually honest. Rather than defending a position, he revisits it after having the Model D on his own desk, and the result is a thoughtful look at what a synth buys you beyond its sound.

Source video: Behringer Model D…I was WRONG (Behringer Model D vs Moog) (Noir Et Blanc Vie, YouTube)

Table of Contents

  • What changed his mind
  • Build quality and the old Behringer reputation
  • What a Moog still has that a clone does not
  • Which one makes more sense?

What changed his mind

The reviewer’s earlier skepticism rested on a simple assumption: that shrinking a Model D, adding features and making it Eurorack-compatible could not be done at this price without corner-cutting. After living with the Behringer, he says he does not see where improvements could have been made. You plug it in and it sounds good. It has the filter you expect and the bite he thought was previously unavailable at this price.

He frames the price gap in the starkest terms: a synth around $300 against one he cites at $3,500. His conclusion is that Behringer delivered more than could reasonably be expected from anything under $1,000 in 2019, and he is careful to say he is talking about value, not a claim that the two are identical.

However the Model D vs Minimoog Model D debate plays out for you, the best test is still playing both instruments side by side.

Build quality and the old Behringer reputation

A large part of the reversal comes down to build quality. He admits he was not a fan of the build on the Deep Mind and had assumed the Model D would be similar. Instead, he found tight-twisting knobs and a solid exterior, with the power switch the one weak point. The switches, he says, are not as robust as the knobs feel, but they are not going to break soon.

He also reflects on how much the manufacturing landscape has changed, arguing that “designed and engineered in the UK, built in China” means something different from what it meant a decade ago. In his words, the gap in production quality between countries is slim enough that without a label he could not tell where it was built.

In the Model D vs Minimoog Model D comparison, price and playability matter as much as raw sound.

What a Moog still has that a clone does not

The reviewer does not use his change of heart to dismiss Moog. He argues the opposite: a Moog is more than a brand. He points to Bob Moog’s legacy, to the fact that the company is employee-owned, and to the idea that buying one is supporting a philosophy as much as buying knobs and buttons. A genuine Moog, he says, will hold its value far better than any Behringer, and he calls that a fact that cannot be argued.

His comparison with cars is memorable. People buy cars and take pictures of them regardless of the badge, and being proud of what you have is a state of mind. Wanting a Moog does not make you an elitist, he says, and wanting the Behringer does not make you a musician who only cares about sound.

The Model D vs Minimoog Model D question rarely has a single right answer, because it depends on how you actually work.

Model D vs Minimoog Model D: which one makes more sense?

The Behringer Model D, in his view, should stand on its own terms: a small, well-built, Eurorack-compatible instrument with three voices that sound like an original Model D, at a price that makes it a heck of a good value. The Moog is a different proposition, closer to a statement piece and a piece of music history.

So the choice is less about which synth wins and more about which values you bring to the purchase. If you want the sound at a budget-friendly price, the Behringer makes a compelling case. If the history, the company and the resale value matter to you, the Moog remains in a category of its own.

That is the Model D vs Minimoog Model D decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.

If you are still undecided in the Model D vs Minimoog Model D matchup, think about which controls you would reach for every day.

Related comparisons

Sources

Bernardo de Azevedo
Written by
Bernardo de AzevedoFounder & Editor

His connection with music began at age 6, in the 1980s, when his father introduced him to Jean-Michel Jarre's Rendez-Vous on vinyl. He works professionally in the legal field, while synthesizers became his space for abstraction and creative exploration. Founder of The Synth Source.