The Electric Circus and the critics
Subotnick, according to Wikipedia, premiered the piece at the opening night of New York’s Electric Circus in June 1967, accompanied by strobe lights. The same article names Seiji Ozawa, Tom Wolfe and members of the Kennedy family among the attendees. That detail appears in only one source I read, so it should be treated with a little caution. His Wikipedia biography confirms that he helped to develop the Electric Circus and its related venue, the Electric Ear, and became their artistic director.
The reviews were mixed. Wikipedia quotes Tod Dockstader calling it a beautiful record in Electronic Music Review. Wendy Carlos praised Subotnick as very talented but called the album a bore, and thought it too long. Asked about Carlos’s Switched-On Bach, Subotnick said, in Wikipedia’s account, that he could never see the point of playing old music on a new invention. The album also sold unusually well for an experimental release. Wikipedia describes it as a surprise hit, among the best-selling classical records of its time, and an underground favourite.
Why a national archive keeps it
The Library of Congress added Silver Apples of the Moon to the National Recording Registry in 2009. Its blog describes the work as the first large-scale original composition made specifically for the disc medium, composed in 1966 and 1967 on commission from Nonesuch. Peter McDowell’s page, which draws on the same recognition, says the Registry named it as one of twenty-five additions that year, whereas Wikipedia says fifty, so I have left the number out.
The Library also holds a physical relic. Subotnick’s own Buchla 100 and his papers are now in the Music Division, and the Library says its team finished restoring the instrument in March 2024. Wikipedia’s biography says the synthesizer came from the New York University residency. The instrument that made the record therefore sits in the same institution that honoured the record.
Recognition accumulated slowly. Wikipedia reports that The Wire ranked the album among its hundred most important records in 1992 and that Pitchfork placed it at number 83 among the best albums of the 1960s in 2017. Another Nonesuch-commissioned tape work, The Wild Bull (dated 1968), followed, and the two pieces were later combined on a Wergo CD. In 1969 Subotnick was invited to help plan the California Institute of the Arts, where he served for about four years as associate dean of the music school before heading its composition program.
Final perspective
Silver Apples of the Moon is a record about format as much as sound. Electronic music had existed for years, but it had not been composed for the long-playing disc, a medium with two sides, a fixed running time and a listener at home. Subotnick accepted those constraints and built a two-part piece around them, one side for pitch and one for pulse.
The commission also shows what a record label can do when it trusts a composer more than a market. Nonesuch’s offer was small by any standard, and Subotnick refused it at first. The second offer, and the thirteen months that followed, produced a work that was still being performed and reconstructed decades later, including a 2018 anniversary performance at REDCAT in Los Angeles. A synthesizer built to avoid the keyboard had found a work that deserved a long-playing record.
That is why the Silver Apples of the Moon story keeps drawing musicians and historians back to it.
Few chapters of synthesizer history show as clearly as Silver Apples of the Moon how far a single idea can travel.
Looking back, the Silver Apples of the Moon episode suggests that the most unusual stories are often the most instructive ones.
For anyone tracing the history of electronic instruments, Silver Apples of the Moon is a name worth remembering.
What makes the Silver Apples of the Moon story memorable is how ordinary the people involved were, and how improbable the outcome turned out to be. Anyone retelling the Silver Apples of the Moon story has to admit that part of it comes down to timing and luck. The Silver Apples of the Moon story also shows how quickly a promising idea can slip out of public view.
Revisiting the Silver Apples of the Moon story today, it is striking how many details were lost or rewritten over the years. Each retelling of the Silver Apples of the Moon story adds a little more context to what the original documents leave out. If there is one lesson in the Silver Apples of the Moon story, it is that technology rarely follows a straight line.
Related stories
Sources