Home›Articles›RCA Mark II Sound Synthesizer: The pop-hit machine that…
Articles

RCA Mark II Sound Synthesizer: The pop-hit machine that ended up serving serialism

RCA Mark II: The RCA Mark II was built by a record and radio giant that wanted automated music, and it ended up in a university basement serving composers…

Bernardo de Azevedo
Bernardo de Azevedo
· Updated
RCA Mark II Sound Synthesizer - historic photo

The RCA Mark II was built by a record and radio giant that wanted automated music, and it ended up in a university basement serving composers who wanted absolute control. It filled a room, used about 1,700 vacuum tubes and was programmed by punching holes in paper. Few people ever learned to use it well, yet it was the machine behind landmark works such as Milton Babbitt’s Philomel.

The story is a good reminder that machines rarely end up where their makers expect. RCA’s engineers set out to understand and automate popular music. What they delivered was an instrument whose only enthusiastic customers were serial composers. The question is how a corporate research project turned into a landmark of American academic electronic music, and why it vanished so quickly once the transistor arrived.

Table of Contents

  • RCA Mark II: a hit-song machine in a research lab
  • From Mark I to Mark II
  • Programming with a paper roll
  • The Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center
  • Babbitt, Wuorinen and the composers who stayed
  • Why transistors ended the story
  • Final perspective

RCA Mark II: a hit-song machine in a research lab

The RCA Mark II traces back to Harry F. Olson and Herbert Belar, RCA engineers who first aimed to build a machine that could write popular songs. According to Perfect Circuit, their earlier Electronic Music Composing Machine analyzed melodies by Stephen Foster, was trained on 11 songs, and used tuning forks for its tones.

The 120 Years of Electronic Music site gives a broader motive: RCA wanted to study what made a hit and generate similar music automatically, and the company also hoped to cut costs by replacing expensive unionized orchestras with automated arrangements.

That commercial plan did not survive the machine. The same source says mainstream musicians found the instrument too complex, so RCA dropped the hit-analysis project before the Mark II was finished. Serialist composers, who wanted to specify every parameter of every note, saw the complexity as an advantage. They became the machine’s audience.

From Mark I to Mark II

Perfect Circuit says the Mark I was unveiled in 1955 and used punched paper input to generate sine waves with electronically vibrated tuning forks. The Mark II followed in 1957 and was far larger: seven feet tall, twenty feet wide, three tons and about 1,700 vacuum tubes, according to the same source.

Wikipedia adds that the design followed U.S. Air Force construction specifications and included an Air Force oscilloscope. It describes the Mark II as a room-sized array of interconnected components, built entirely from vacuum tubes, with twice as many tone oscillators as the Mark I, a white noise generator and four-note polyphony.

The Mark II added what a composer needed to shape sound. Perfect Circuit lists sine, sawtooth and triangle waveforms, high-pass and low-pass filters, portamento and envelopes, with attack times from 1 millisecond to 2 seconds and decay times from 4 milliseconds to 19 seconds. Signals were routed by hand between modules.

The 120 Years site cites two earlier precedents, the Givelet-Coupleux Organ of 1930 and the Hanert Electric Orchestra of 1945. It says the result offered millions of possible settings, and notes that oscillator counts doubled from 12 in the Mark I to 24 in the Mark II.

Programming with a paper roll

The machine had no keyboard in the musical sense. The composer typed a score in binary code on a typewriter-style keyboard, which punched holes in a paper roll resembling a player-piano roll. According to the 120 Years site, each parameter, including pitch, timbre, volume and envelope, used four columns of holes, giving sixteen values for each aspect. The roll moved at 10 centimeters per second, which set the fastest tempo at 240 beats per minute.

Wikipedia describes the output as going to a synchronized record lathe. The composer compared the recording with the score, adjusted the holes and tried again, a process that replaced the physical cutting and splicing of magnetic tape. It also demanded extensive configuration before a score would run, and Wikipedia says few people became proficient. There is a small discrepancy among the sources on the medium, since Wikipedia says punched cards while the other two sources say paper roll or tape. The paper roll is the better-supported description.

The Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center

The Mark II found its home at the Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center, founded by the Columbia professors Vladimir Ussachevsky and Otto Luening and the Princeton professors Milton Babbitt and Roger Sessions. Wikipedia says the machine was delivered in 1957 and built to the specifications of Ussachevsky and Babbitt. The center was officially established in 1959 with a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation, which financed the acquisition of the synthesizer from RCA. Perfect Circuit puts the grant at 175,000 dollars.

The work had begun earlier. Wikipedia says electronic music activity at Columbia and Barnard started in 1951 as the Columbia Experimental Music Studio, and that the name changed to Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center in 1958. The center’s address was Prentis Hall, 632 West 125th Street in New York City, according to Wikipedia. The facility covers 5,400 square feet, and visitors and students included Edgard Varèse, Wendy Carlos and Mario Davidovsky, among others.

A 1964 Columbia Records album titled Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center was produced principally on the RCA synthesizer. The Mark II was the flagship, but Perfect Circuit quotes the composer Alice Shields saying that, to her knowledge, only Babbitt and Wuorinen actually composed on it.

Babbitt, Wuorinen and the composers who stayed

Milton Babbitt became the instrument’s great advocate. Wikipedia names Vision and Prayer and Philomel among the works made with it, and Perfect Circuit adds Ensembles for Synthesizer and Composition for Synthesizer from 1961 to 1964. It reports that Babbitt used the Mark II until 1972 and did not further process the output. Philomel premiered in 1964, and Wendy Carlos helped run the tape machine on that occasion, according to the same article.

Charles Wuorinen’s Time’s Encomium, composed in 1968 and 1969, won the 1970 Pulitzer Prize in Music, as Wikipedia reports for the center. Perfect Circuit calls it the first wholly electronic piece to win a Pulitzer. Babbitt himself was candid about the machine’s temperament. Perfect Circuit reports that he considered it unreliable and never knew what would go wrong next.

Why transistors ended the story

The Mark II was expensive to replicate and fragile in practice. Wikipedia says it was surpassed in the mid-1960s by more reliable and affordable solid-state synthesizers from Buchla and Moog. Perfect Circuit reports that a Buchla 100 Series system was added to the center in 1965, and that the Buchla has since been restored and is still in use.

The Mark II had a quieter fate. According to Wikipedia it remains at the Columbia University Computer Music Center but is non-functional. Perfect Circuit adds that its room is now an office. The 120 Years site says it was vandalized in the early 1970s and little used afterward. Wikipedia also records that R.

Luke DuBois was the last composer to get sound from it, for a brief piece on a 1997 album. An RCA Mark III was conceived but never built, and RCA chose not to stay in the synthesizer business. Columbia bought enough spare parts to build two duplicates.

Final perspective

The RCA Mark II shows what happens when automation meets authorship. Its sponsors wanted a machine that would decide what music should sound like. Its users wanted a machine that would do exactly what they told it, nothing more, and they accepted a laborious process of punched paper to get it. The second group got what they wanted, and the first group got nothing.

It also marks a turning point in how we think about synthesis. The Mark II demanded that every sound be specified in advance on paper, and it filled a room to do it, while the solid-state systems that replaced it were more reliable and affordable. The RCA Mark II remained a laboratory instrument, remarkable for what it made possible and for how few people could use it.

That is why the RCA Mark II story keeps drawing musicians and historians back to it.

Few chapters of synthesizer history show as clearly as RCA Mark II how far a single idea can travel.

Looking back, the RCA Mark II episode suggests that the most unusual stories are often the most instructive ones.

What makes the RCA Mark II story memorable is how ordinary the people involved were, and how improbable the outcome turned out to be. Anyone retelling the RCA Mark II story has to admit that part of it comes down to timing and luck. The RCA Mark II story also shows how quickly a promising idea can slip out of public view.

Revisiting the RCA Mark II story today, it is striking how many details were lost or rewritten over the years. Each retelling of the RCA Mark II story adds a little more context to what the original documents leave out. If there is one lesson in the RCA Mark II story, it is that technology rarely follows a straight line.

Related stories

Sources

Bernardo de Azevedo
Written by
Bernardo de AzevedoFounder & Editor

His connection with music began at age 6, in the 1980s, when his father introduced him to Jean-Michel Jarre's Rendez-Vous on vinyl. He works professionally in the legal field, while synthesizers became his space for abstraction and creative exploration. Founder of The Synth Source.