Home›Articles›Raymond Scott and the Electronium: The cartoon bandlead…
Articles

Raymond Scott and the Electronium: The cartoon bandleader who built a composing machine

Raymond Scott: Plenty of people have heard Raymond Scott’s music without knowing his name. His swing tunes from the late 1930s were later chopped up and…

Bernardo de Azevedo
Bernardo de Azevedo
· Updated
Raymond Scott - illustration

Plenty of people have heard Raymond Scott’s music without knowing his name. His swing tunes from the late 1930s were later chopped up and reused in Looney Tunes cartoons, which made him an accidental fixture of animation. Meanwhile, in a house full of homemade electronics, he was working on something more ambitious: a machine that would compose and perform music with its operator, like a duet.

That machine was the Electronium, and the best word for its fate is unfinished. Motown’s founder ordered one, Scott went to work for the label, and no Motown record using the invention has been identified. The question worth asking is why a man who was decades ahead on sequencing, sound design and generative music left so little in the way of a finished instrument.

Table of Contents

  • Raymond Scott: from swing to cartoons
  • Manhattan Research Inc.: a private laboratory
  • The Clavivox and a young Bob Moog
  • Soothing Sounds for Baby
  • The Electronium: a duet with a machine
  • Motown, 1970 to 1977
  • Final perspective

Raymond Scott: from swing to cartoons

Raymond Scott was born Harry Warnow on 10 September 1908, according to Wikipedia, and studied at Juilliard. He formed the Raymond Scott Quintette at CBS in late 1936, and despite the name it had six members. Its first recordings date from 20 February 1937, and the tunes included Powerhouse, The Penguin and Twilight in Turkey.

His cartoon fame was an accident. Wikipedia stresses that Scott never contracted for animation work. In 1943 he sold his music publishing catalog to Warner Bros., which allowed the studio’s composer Carl Stalling to adapt his pieces, and those adaptations show up in more than 120 Looney Tunes and Merrie Melodies. So a generation heard Scott’s rhythms attached to Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck, while Scott himself was already moving toward electronics.

Manhattan Research Inc.: a private laboratory

Scott established Manhattan Research Inc. in 1946, according to Wikipedia and the Raymond Scott archive timeline, as a company to design and sell electronic audio devices. The 120 Years of Electronic Music site calls it a commercial electronic music studio that he designed and built. Its equipment included envelope shapers, ring modulators, electronic drum generators and variable wave shape generators. The same site says his first electronic instrument was the Karloff, built in 1948 for sound effects in advertising and film.

The company did real commercial work. Wikipedia says Scott made electronic jingles for products including Sprite, Nescafé and Baltimore Gas and Electric. Thom Holmes reports that in the late 1940s Scott’s home in North Hills, Long Island, had eight rooms devoted to electronic experiments. A 2000 release on Basta collected recordings from this period, a two-CD set of 69 tracks recorded between 1953 and 1969, according to the Raymond Scott archive.

The Clavivox and a young Bob Moog

The Clavivox was Scott’s keyboard take on the theremin’s gliding tone. The archive timeline says he began developing it in 1952, partly with his daughter Carolyn in mind, and that a US patent for a keyboard-operated electrical musical instrument was granted in 1956. According to 120 Years of Electronic Music it used a three-octave keyboard and vacuum-tube oscillators, and Scott used it for eerie, theremin-like effects in cartoon scores. It was meant for mass production, but the site says its complexity and fragility made that impractical.

A young Robert Moog entered the story here. The archive timeline says Scott met him in 1955 and ordered a theremin sub-assembly from him for the Clavivox. In an interview posted on the same site, Moog recalls working on the sub-assembly with his father, and says he was a Columbia student when he first visited Scott, before 1957. Wikipedia says only that Moog met Scott in the 1950s and designed circuits for him in the 1960s, and that Moog considered him an important influence.

Soothing Sounds for Baby

In the early 1960s Scott made one of the strangest records of the period. Soothing Sounds for Baby came out as three volumes on Epic, aimed at babies aged 1 to 6 months, 6 to 12 months and 12 to 18 months. Thom Holmes reports that the music grew more complex with each volume, and that the Gesell Institute of Child Development advised on how complex the sounds should be for each age group.

Sources disagree on the date. The Raymond Scott archive and Frieze say 1963, while Holmes and part of Wikipedia say 1964, and Frieze uses both. Frieze also reports the initial release sold poorly, though without figures. Holmes says Scott used his own instruments, including the Clavivox and the Electronium, along with a multitrack recording system. As a product it flopped, but as a document of a composer who saw electronic sound as functional, even therapeutic, it was far ahead of the curve.

The Electronium: a duet with a machine

The Electronium was Scott’s last and most ambitious project. According to the Wikipedia article on the machine, development began in 1959, and a workable unit existed by 1969. Scott kept modifying it until his death in 1994, and it was never finished. The Raymond Scott archive says he created the Electronium Corporation of America in 1967. Holmes dates the work as continuing from about 1949 to 1972, so the timeline depends on what counts as the starting point.

The machine had no keyboard. It was controlled with switches and knobs, and Scott described its results as a kind of duet between the composer and the machine, according to Wikipedia, which calls it an early analog machine combining a synthesizer with algorithmic composition. Google Arts and Culture, working from the Raymond Scott Archives, says one panel generated semi-random pitch excursions that acted as the machine’s composing partner.

Scott claimed to have spent eleven years and close to a million dollars on it, a figure that comes from his own account.

Motown, 1970 to 1977

In August 1970, according to Google Arts and Culture, Motown founder Berry Gordy read about the Electronium in a Variety article, and in September Scott ordered one for the label. After a six-month residency in Los Angeles, Scott became Director of Electronic Music Research and Development. Wikipedia says he held the position until 1977. Gordy asked for a keyboard so a player could perform with the machine, and Scott reluctantly added one hidden in a drawer in the base.

The collaboration produced little. Wikipedia reports that no Motown recordings using Scott’s inventions have been publicly identified, and Google Arts and Culture says that as far as it can determine, the Electronium was never used on a Motown record. Guy Costa, Motown’s chief engineer, said the machine never really got finalized and that Scott had trouble letting go. Gordy’s interest faded, and Scott kept working at home until strokes ended his career. Wikipedia places a stroke in 1987, and he died on 8 February 1994.

Final perspective

Scott’s story is usually told as a tragedy of the unfinished, and there is truth in that. The Electronium was not a product, the Clavivox never reached mass production and the baby records sold poorly. Yet each project asked a question that later instruments would answer. Could a machine propose notes while a person decides which ones stay? Could electronic sound be designed for a purpose, whether a jingle or a nursery? Those questions are now routine in sequencers, generative software and sound design for media.

Scott’s reputation has also been revived. Wikipedia says interest returned in the early 1990s after Irwin Chusid’s visit, and that the Columbia compilation Reckless Nights and Turkish Twilights appeared in 1992. The Raymond Scott archive notes that the 2019 track Tempo by Lizzo and Missy Elliott samples Nescafé from the Manhattan Research compilation, which brought a track from Scott’s commercial work into a pop record decades later.

What remains of the machine is a physical object in need of repair. Wikipedia says the only known surviving Electronium was bought by Mark Mothersbaugh of Devo in the mid-1990s, and Google Arts and Culture reports that in 2010 it moved to Oregon for volunteer restoration and is now in storage in Los Angeles, with Brian Kehew and Gotye described as planning to revive it.

The sources disagree about the exact year of purchase. What they agree on is that Raymond Scott’s best-known music came from his quintette, while his most revealing work was done in a workshop.

Related stories

Sources

Bernardo de Azevedo
Written by
Bernardo de AzevedoFounder & Editor

His connection with music began at age 6, in the 1980s, when his father introduced him to Jean-Michel Jarre's Rendez-Vous on vinyl. He works professionally in the legal field, while synthesizers became his space for abstraction and creative exploration. Founder of The Synth Source.