That punch has practical consequences. The Prophet-6 can take center stage in a mix, and he notes the common complaint that it can be too powerful and needs to be carved with EQ. His answer is that this is how mixing works: it is easier to start with a heavy instrument and take things away than to try to add weight to a thin one.
In the Prophet-6 vs Prophet Rev2 comparison, price and playability matter as much as raw sound.
Limitations that work as a feature
On paper the Prophet-6 has fewer tools than the Rev2. It has one LFO instead of four, no mod matrix, a limited set of routing options and two ADSRs instead of three. The reviewer does not treat that as a weakness. He argues that the interface is thoughtfully designed, and that the routing you do have can lead to interesting results you might not reach with infinite possibilities.
He also points to the Prophet-6’s two filters, including a high-pass filter in the effects section that can help carve space for the synth in a mix. By contrast, he mentions that the Rev2 can do things the Prophet-6 cannot, such as routing noise as a modulation source to the filter cutoff, which he describes as one of his favorite tricks.
The Prophet-6 vs Prophet Rev2 question rarely has a single right answer, because it depends on how you actually work.
Prophet-6 vs Prophet Rev2: which one makes more sense?
His summary is practical. Choose the Rev2 if you want a versatile sound design instrument with evolving pads, more voices and more modulation, and if value matters, since he notes it is also cheaper. Choose the Prophet-6 if you want one great analog polysynth that can be the featured sound in a production, particularly if your mix is not already crowded.
The most honest part of his conclusion is that he would be hard-pressed to pick a favorite. That is exactly why this comparison is interesting: the two synths do not sit on a single scale from better to worse. They solve two different musical problems.
That is the Prophet-6 vs Prophet Rev2 decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.
If you are still undecided in the Prophet-6 vs Prophet Rev2 matchup, think about which controls you would reach for every day.
Related comparisons
Sources