The more interesting differences are in the sound engine. The Prophet-5 has one more option in the poly-mod section, lets you switch between different filter revisions, and has a Vintage knob that increases the analog imperfection. The Pro-800 has an additional VBR LFO, which he finds very nice, and lets you choose between different envelope characteristics.
The sound
He was surprised by how small the differences were in most parts of his A/B comparison. He is careful to explain the scope: he focused on sequence sounds with controlled polyphony and deliberately avoided pad sounds with long release phases, because there the eight voices of the Pro-800 would be too obviously an advantage. He also resisted switching the Vintage effect on the Prophet-5, which sounds really great on sequences.
Pro-800 vs Prophet-5: which one makes more sense?
His verdict is that both provide an excellent sound, and in the end it is perhaps a matter of taste which kind of Prophet sound you prefer. What impresses him most is the price: it is a miracle that Behringer can offer an eight-voice poly in a range where other companies sell monophonic synthesizers, and he predicts it will fundamentally change the market. Practically, the Pro-800 gives you more voices, a sequencer and an arpeggiator for far less money. The Prophet-5 gives you the heavier build, the Vintage control, filter revisions and the legend itself.
That is the Pro-800 vs Prophet-5 decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.
If you can, audition the Pro-800 and the Prophet-5 in the same room, through the same speakers or headphones, and with the same patch ideas. Start with a basic sound on each, then move on to the kind of part you actually play: a bass line, a pad, a lead or a layered keyboard sound.
Pay attention to how quickly you can get to a sound you like, how the controls feel under your hands and whether you keep reaching for the same instrument. That kind of hands-on time will tell you more about the Pro-800 vs Prophet-5 question than any list of specifications.
Related comparisons
Sources