Both share a polyphonic modulation idea: an oscillator can be switched to low-frequency or audible-frequency mode so that each note modulates its destination at a different rate, producing the crazy sounds for which the Prophet-5 is legendary.
Other differences: the Memorymoog has more envelope control, more keyboard tracking settings, an arpeggiator, a sequencer on some units and MIDI, which makes it feel more modern. On the Prophet-5, glide is available only in unison mode, whereas the Memorymoog allows it in all modes. The Memorymoog’s oscillator A offers three waveforms versus two on the Prophet-5.
In the Memorymoog vs Prophet-5 comparison, price and playability matter as much as raw sound.
Tone and usability
The tonal difference is the heart of the video. The Memorymoog is far more harmonically complex, probably because of the three oscillators, with a lot of movement inside the sound. The Prophet-5 is cleaner, still rich and pleasant, but it does not occupy the whole spectrum the way the Memorymoog does. He says the Prophet-5 is probably much more usable in a multi-part mix, while the Memorymoog is amazing to simply play and let the sound wash over you.
On the used market, he quotes Prophet-5 Rev 3s at roughly 6 to 9 thousand dollars and Memorymoogs at 10 to 15 thousand. Memorymoogs are less reliable, although a modernisation can prevent many of the original problems.
The Memorymoog vs Prophet-5 question rarely has a single right answer, because it depends on how you actually work.
Memorymoog vs Prophet-5: which one makes more sense?
He does not pick one. Both can go to similar places in sound design but are fundamentally different in tone. The Prophet-5 is the practical choice, available as a modern reissue and in good software versions, and sits well in a mix. The Memorymoog is the choice if you want maximum harmonic depth and are willing to pay more and take on the reliability risk. For anyone wanting the Moog lineage today, he points to the Moog One as the closest modern relative.
That is the Memorymoog vs Prophet-5 decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.
Related comparisons
Sources