In the Poly D vs Model D comparison, price and playability matter as much as raw sound.
Keys, connectivity and effects
The Poly D has a 37-key keyboard, which has no aftertouch but works well as a MIDI controller. He notes a third of the extra money goes into the keyboard, since a comparable controller costs around £90. It also has a MIDI hub with in, out and through, CV in and out, and full quarter-inch outputs. The Model D, on the other hand, can be taken out of its shell and installed in a Eurorack, a point he credits to his colleague.
On effects, the Poly D has a drive circuit with a tone control, though he wishes it had a blend knob, as it is rather dry and lo-fi at high settings. It also has a real analog chorus with two modes that can be combined, giving proper stereo and stereo outputs. The Model D has no effects.
The Poly D vs Model D question rarely has a single right answer, because it depends on how you actually work.
Sequencer, arpeggiator and looks
The Poly D adds a polyphonic sequencer and arpeggiator, another feature worth roughly £90 on its own. He adds a shallow point: with its wooden design it looks like a piece of furniture for the studio.
Poly D vs Model D: which one makes more sense?
If you will use the chords, the keyboard, the effects, the arpeggiator and the I/O, the Poly D justifies its price. If you are not into chords or need a monophonic bass and lead synth to drop into a Eurorack or desktop setup, the Model D is, in his words, an amazing deal. He suggests trying them in a store and notes the price difference can seem smaller when spread out over monthly finance.
That is the Poly D vs Model D decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.
Related comparisons
Sources