The kick drum question
Rhythm is where the sources split. Wikipedia says the hi-hat was made by processing white noise from the Moog with an envelope. It also says the Moog could not produce a satisfactory kick drum, so the drummer Keith Forsey played the kick, making it the only element other than the vocals not played by a machine.
Moroder told Noisey that percussion was built from white noise with certain frequencies filtered out, and that Forsey played all the drums except the bass drum, which he said was the part the Moog could not do convincingly. Forsey, he added, needed five or six takes. Mojo agrees that Forsey supplied the bass drum.
Sound on Sound tells it differently. Its feature says Wedel simulated the hi-hat, snare, bass drum and a swell pad on the Moog, and it links the four-on-the-floor kick pattern to an earlier session jam by Forsey. Since three sources point to a played kick and one to a synthesized one, the cautious statement is that Forsey is widely credited with the kick, though accounts differ.
A B-side that turned into the A-side
Mojo reports that the track first appeared as the B-side to “Can’t We Just Sit Down (And Talk It Over),” until club success made it the A-side. Moroder described it to Mojo as just an album track, and said that he later sensed it could point to the future but did not expect its impact. He also said he had considered the cantina music from Star Wars as a model before deciding the sound had to be made entirely with computers.
The single reached number one on the UK Singles Chart in July 1977 and stayed there for four weeks, according to Wikipedia. It reached number six on the Billboard Hot 100 in the week of November 12, 1977, and number three in West Germany. Sound on Sound adds that Casablanca’s Neil Bogart asked for three edits of the song for the single release, and that Bellotte thought they improved its flow.
The remixes and the reputation
The reputation of the record grew from its listeners. Sound on Sound quotes Brian Eno in 1977 calling it the one to look to, saying that this is it and to look no further. Wikipedia relays David Bowie’s recollection that Eno came running in during the recording of Bowie’s Berlin albums and said he had heard the sound of the future, predicting that it would change club music for the next fifteen years.
The DJ Patrick Cowley made an extended remix from a vinyl copy of the original, not from Moroder’s master tapes. Early versions circulated as an underground bootleg before the Disconet remix service picked them up. In mid-1980, it was released on a limited DJ-only Disconet pressing titled “I Feel Love / I Feel Megalove,” which became highly sought after.
Casablanca released the remix as a 12-inch in the UK in 1982. Mojo lists the Human League, Blondie, Sparks and Simple Minds among admirers, and notes that Moroder later worked with Daft Punk on Random Access Memories in 2013.
Final perspective
The history of I Feel Love shows how much of an electronic record’s precision comes from human labor. The Moog was unstable, so it was retuned and recorded in short bursts. The clock was unreliable, so a technician locked it to a tape pulse. Each sound took about half an hour to patch by hand. The mechanical perfection that later producers copied was, in practice, a long series of repairs.
It also shows how little a creator’s intention can say about a record’s meaning. The men who made it treated it as an album closer. Listeners heard a template. The Moog modular on this track was borrowed, and so, in a way, was the future it seemed to describe.
That is why the I Feel Love story keeps drawing musicians and historians back to it.
Few chapters of synthesizer history show as clearly as I Feel Love how far a single idea can travel.
Looking back, the I Feel Love episode suggests that the most unusual stories are often the most instructive ones.
For anyone tracing the history of electronic instruments, I Feel Love is a name worth remembering.
Related stories
Sources