Table of Contents
- Hartmann Neuron: a sampler that did not want to be a sampler
- The people behind the machine
- Resynthesis, neural networks and what the marketing promised
- What Sound on Sound found in 2003
- The hardware that behaved like a computer
- A cheaper Neuron, and a website that went dark
- Who still plays it
- Final perspective
Hartmann Neuron: a sampler that did not want to be a sampler
The core idea of the Hartmann Neuron was that a sample is a dead end. A sampler plays back a recording, with a bit of filtering and looping. The Neuron instead analyzed a recording, built a model of it, and resynthesized sound from the model. Wikipedia’s account says the model could then be adjusted through musical properties, such as the body size and material of the imagined instrument.
The instrument was designed and built by the industrial designer Axel Hartmann under the name Hartmann Music in Germany, over a development period that Wikipedia gives as 2001 to 2005. Its infobox lists 2003 as the date. Launch price was about $5,000, and Synthtopia gives a manufacturer’s suggested price of $4,990 or €4,890. In Britain, Sound on Sound put it at £3,499.99 including VAT.
The people behind the machine
Axel Hartmann is better known as a designer than as an engineer. In his NAMM oral history, recorded in January 2019, he is described as a music industry designer with more than three decades of experience, who began working with Waldorf Music soon after finishing his design studies. His Waldorf Wave won the Red Dot Design Award in 1992. The same page credits him with releasing the Neuron around the turn of the millennium and notes that film composer Hans Zimmer valued its cinematic sound.
The synthesis technology came from outside. Wikipedia credits Stephan Bernsee of the software company Prosoniq. Bernsee, born Stephan Sprenger in 1971, founded Prosoniq and is described as the principal developer of the Neuron’s synthesis technology. Sound on Sound’s review calls the method Multi Component Particle Transform Synthesis and names Stephan Sprenger as its designer. Taken together, those sources point to a division of labor in which Hartmann shaped the instrument physically and Prosoniq supplied the engine inside it.
Resynthesis, neural networks and what the marketing promised
Bernsee’s own blog gives the clearest account of the idea. Classical resynthesis, introduced in the 1980s, rebuilds a sound as a sum of sine tones at different frequencies and amplitudes. It becomes unwieldy with hundreds of tones, and sine tones handle short, impulsive sounds poorly, often producing a diffuse quality called phasiness. The Neuron instead adapts its basis to the sound being modeled, which, he wrote, allows faithful reproduction and wide modification.
The blog describes the model creation as a pattern recognition process based on artificial neural networks. Because the analysis is computationally heavy, it was done ahead of time in a separate program called Modelmaker, not while playing. A complexity parameter limits how detailed the models become, and complex material such as drum loops is represented by a time-variable morph between models.
Hartmann’s marketing leaned hard on the neural network. Sound on Sound’s reviewer found that, as tested, the Neuron did not select its own parameter sets in the way the marketing implied. The user chose the settings.
What Sound on Sound found in 2003
Gordon Reid reviewed the Neuron for Sound on Sound in August 2003, and the verdict was a careful one. He called it something of a mixed bag and an expensive work in progress, and said he could not wholeheartedly recommend it. He thought the factory sounds were flat without effects, and that many models had loop artifacts and octave jumps.
He also praised what worked. The real-time controls, especially recorded joystick movements that Hartmann called stick animation, gave a degree of control he said was unavailable elsewhere. Effects made pads and textures more interesting, and the machine did not crash during the review. He thought it suited sampling, mangling, sound effects and foley.
The most pointed remark concerned timing. The review questioned the awards the Neuron had already received before the first units shipped. Synthtopia, writing in 2009, makes the same point in its own words: the awards were presented nine months ahead of delivery, and the instrument was more ambitious than the company’s resources allowed.
The hardware that behaved like a computer
A good deal of the Neuron’s trouble came from being a computer in a keyboard case. Wikipedia describes a PC base running an early version of Gentoo Linux with a custom synthesis application and a custom sound card, in a heavy aluminum chassis. The Sound on Sound review lists a 20 GB internal drive, a boot time of about 40 seconds that the reviewer found unsuitable for live use, and a fan he considered annoying in a studio.