Listening to oscillators, triangle waves and FM, he says he struggles to find big obvious differences. The FM behaves almost identically, with one nuance: it is not quite as high pitched on the Behringer. The noise modulation also sounds the same to him, and when he sets up identical sequencer patterns both machines produce the same kind of tones.
In the Edge vs DFAM comparison, price and playability matter as much as raw sound.
Where the differences show up
The clearest difference in his testing is the VCA decay. With the decay fully up, the cutoff open and the resonance down, the Moog has a much longer tail than the Behringer. He is careful to note that he is using a pre-production Edge, so this may change, and that he only noticed it after hours of playing because, with a sequencer, long tails rarely matter. If you plan to use the machine for effects or sustained synth parts, however, it could be a factor.
Pink noise is the other distinction. The Edge can switch the noise color, which changes how the filter and oscillators sit in the mix, while the DFAM cannot.
The Edge vs DFAM question rarely has a single right answer, because it depends on how you actually work.
Edge vs DFAM: which one makes more sense?
His verdict is that the Edge does the same job as the DFAM, in the same sonic space, although the two are not identical and he could probably match them better if he were obsessed. For someone who does not need Eurorack and who values MIDI, USB and a lower barrier to entry, the Edge makes a good case. For a player who wants the Moog name, the longer VCA tail and a Eurorack-compatible module, the DFAM remains the original.
That is the Edge vs DFAM decision in short: match the instrument to the sound and workflow you actually want, and weigh the price difference before you commit.
Related comparisons
Sources