Home›Articles›Edgar Winter’s Frankenstein: A monster stitched from ta…
Articles

Edgar Winter’s Frankenstein: A monster stitched from tape and an ARP 2600 keyboard on a guitar strap

Edgar Winter: In May 1973 an instrumental topped the American singles chart. It had no vocals, a title that came from a studio joke, and a structure that…

Bernardo de Azevedo
Bernardo de Azevedo
· Updated
Edgar Winter's Frankenstein - historic photo

In May 1973 an instrumental topped the American singles chart. It had no vocals, a title that came from a studio joke, and a structure that existed only because producers cut it up with scissors. It also carried one of the most memorable images in synthesizer history: a keyboard player walking the stage with an ARP 2600 hung round his neck like a guitar.

Edgar Winter’s “Frankenstein” is therefore two stories at once, one about tape editing and one about a legend. The legend says Winter strapped a whole synthesizer to his body. Is that true, and what exactly did the song’s makers do to turn a jam into a number one hit?

Table of Contents

  • Edgar Winter Frankenstein: a riff that was never meant for the album
  • The Hit Factory and the china marker
  • A name from the control room
  • Why the ARP 2600 and not a Moog
  • The keytar legend, tested
  • A B-side takes the chart
  • Final perspective

Edgar Winter Frankenstein: a riff that was never meant for the album

Edgar Winter was born in Beaumont, Texas, on 28 December 1946, and he formed the Edgar Winter Group in late 1972 with Dan Hartman, Ronnie Montrose and Chuck Ruff. The album They Only Come Out at Night appeared in November 1972 and reached number 3 on the Billboard 200, according to Wikipedia.

“Frankenstein” was its only instrumental, and Wikipedia says it was not originally planned for the record and was added at the last minute. Its roots go back further. Winter told Synthtopia that the riff was first written while he played with his brother Johnny Winter’s band, and Stereogum, citing the same story, says it was performed on Johnny’s Woodstock stage.

Wikipedia adds that a 1970 version was played at the Royal Albert Hall with Johnny Winter and was eventually released in 2004. The working titles were “The Instrumental” and “The Double Drum Song,” because of the duel between two drummers at its heart.

The Hit Factory and the china marker

Mix magazine places the recording at The Hit Factory in New York. Rick Derringer produced, Bill Szymczyk engineered, and the album was recorded to two-inch tape on an Ampex 16-track machine. The band played live, except for the drum trade-off, which was recorded separately to a click track and inserted into the master. Derringer described the control room’s custom console as sitting somewhere between an API and a Trident, and Mix adds that Szymczyk used a device called The Cube to add a processed second channel for a stereo effect.

The raw performances were long. Winter recalled a jam that ran fifteen or twenty minutes, and Derringer suggested editing it into something usable. Mix reports that the takes, each eleven to fifteen minutes long, were cut to about seven minutes. Szymczyk edited the two-inch multitrack tapes by marking them with a china marker and cutting. Winter then added one overdub, a second guitar part in the jazzy interlude, and a second round of edits on the stereo mix brought the track to 4 minutes 45 seconds.

According to the same account, Derringer, Szymczyk and a record-company representative also made a 3:28 radio edit without Winter present. Winter described the process as being like cutting a diamond.

Synthtopia describes the editing session as pieces of tape spread around the control room while the group worked out how to reassemble them. Stereogum’s writer says the editing sounds seamless given the technology of the time.

A name from the control room

The title came from the process. Wikipedia credits drummer Chuck Ruff with coining it, in reference to the heavy editing of the original recording. Mix, Synthtopia and Stereogum all repeat a version in which Ruff, hearing the playback, remarks that it is like Frankenstein. Winter told Synthtopia that he liked the name, and Wikipedia says he cited its fit with the track’s monster-like, lumbering beat.

It is a rare case where a title describes a method. The finished record is a body assembled from pieces, and the studio staff knew it. That fact slightly complicates the usual story of a spontaneous jam captured on tape. The jam existed, but the record is a composed edit of it.

Why the ARP 2600 and not a Moog

Winter’s synthesizer was an ARP 2600. Mix says he bought it at Manny’s Music in New York City in 1971, and he told Synthtopia that he had looked at Moogs and ARPs there. His reason for preferring the ARP was practical: the Moog had its keyboard built into the control unit, whereas the 2600 had a separate, remote keyboard. Mix puts the same point in terms of connection, saying the keyboard linked to the base unit by a single cable, so he could move around the stage.

The studio patches were also named. Mix lists “Frank Solo,” used for the main riff, bass line and solo, and “Acid Bath,” used for the 6/8 section. Wikipedia’s personnel list credits Winter with the ARP 2600, electric piano, alto saxophone and timbales on the track, with Ronnie Montrose on guitar, Dan Hartman on bass and Ruff on drums. For the studio drum duel, Mix says Winter switched to timbales because two drum kits were hard to manage on stage.

The keytar legend, tested

The legend says Winter wore an entire ARP 2600 on a strap. The MatrixSynth blog tackled this directly in 2007. Its author had heard that the Edgar Winter Group played the synthesizer as a strap-on keytar and found the idea hard to believe given the instrument’s size, calling it “pretty insane” before a video clip settled the matter. Readers pointed out that the keyboard controller was separate from the 2600 cabinet, and the author later admitted it was one of his less brilliant moments.

Winter’s own account matches that. In the Synthtopia interview he says the ARP’s remote keyboard looked light enough to put a strap on like a guitar, and that is what he did. Wikipedia’s article on the song says Winter became the first to strap a keyboard around his neck in live performance, and its article on Winter says he invented the keyboard body strap.

Stereogum notes that he came up with hanging a keyboard from a guitar strap before the word “keytar” existed. So the truth is slightly smaller and more interesting than the myth. What he strapped on was the keyboard, and what he gained was the mobility of a guitarist.

A B-side takes the chart

The song was released as a single on Epic on 21 February 1973, and it started life as the B-side of “Hangin’ Around.” Wikipedia says disc jockeys in the United States and Canada were flooded with calls about it, so the label reversed the two sides. It reached number one on the Billboard Hot 100 for one week in May 1973, and Stereogum gives the date as 26 May. The Recording Industry Association of America certified it gold on 19 June 1973.

Later honours were mixed with oddities. Rolling Stone ranked it number seven on its list of the twenty-five best rock instrumentals, and Wikipedia notes that Winter remade it in 1983 with a more synthesizer- and beat-heavy arrangement and a video in which he plays Dr. Frankenstein. The track has also been covered widely, including a Phish performance that the band has repeated, according to the same article, ninety-four times.

Final perspective

“Frankenstein” is a reminder that studio craft shaped the sound of early-1970s rock as much as spontaneity did. The record sounds like a group playing flat out, and parts of it are exactly that. But the structure that millions heard on the radio was made by marking and cutting tape, and the title was a joke that happened to tell the truth.

The synthesizer story has a similar lesson about what makes an instrument usable on stage. The ARP 2600 mattered to Winter because its keyboard could be separated and carried, and that made it a stage instrument rather than a studio fixture. A portable controller on a strap is common now. In 1973 it was a way of looking like a guitarist while sounding like nobody else.

That is why the Edgar Winter story keeps drawing musicians and historians back to it.

Few chapters of synthesizer history show as clearly as Edgar Winter how far a single idea can travel.

Looking back, the Edgar Winter episode suggests that the most unusual stories are often the most instructive ones.

For anyone tracing the history of electronic instruments, Edgar Winter is a name worth remembering.

What makes the Edgar Winter story memorable is how ordinary the people involved were, and how improbable the outcome turned out to be. Anyone retelling the Edgar Winter story has to admit that part of it comes down to timing and luck. The Edgar Winter story also shows how quickly a promising idea can slip out of public view.

Revisiting the Edgar Winter story today, it is striking how many details were lost or rewritten over the years. Each retelling of the Edgar Winter story adds a little more context to what the original documents leave out. If there is one lesson in the Edgar Winter story, it is that technology rarely follows a straight line.

Related stories

Sources

Bernardo de Azevedo
Written by
Bernardo de AzevedoFounder & Editor

His connection with music began at age 6, in the 1980s, when his father introduced him to Jean-Michel Jarre's Rendez-Vous on vinyl. He works professionally in the legal field, while synthesizers became his space for abstraction and creative exploration. Founder of The Synth Source.