Home›Articles›Close Encounters and the ARP 2500: The five notes, 350 …
Articles

Close Encounters and the ARP 2500: The five notes, 350 candidates and the engineer who became an actor

ARP 2500: In Close Encounters of the Third Kind, humanity speaks to an alien mothership through a five-note phrase played on a synthesizer. The phrase is…

Bernardo de Azevedo
Bernardo de Azevedo
· Updated
Close Encounters and the ARP 2500 - historic photo

In Close Encounters of the Third Kind, humanity speaks to an alien mothership through a five-note phrase played on a synthesizer. The phrase is among the most famous in film music, and the instrument at the centre of the scene was a rare, expensive ARP 2500 that had been brought to the set for a very different reason than acting.

The real history is stranger than the movie’s. John Williams wrote hundreds of candidates before one was chosen, the synthesizer’s operator was the engineer who had been sent to install it, and the instrument itself was a commercial failure whose modules ARP later condensed into the cheaper 2600. How did a machine that barely sold turn up in a major film of 1977?

Table of Contents

  • ARP 2500: the expensive modular nobody could sell
  • Williams, Spielberg and the problem of five notes
  • A mathematician’s answer
  • An installer becomes a musician
  • The scene at Devils Tower
  • What the film did for the ARP 2500
  • Final perspective

ARP 2500: the expensive modular nobody could sell

The ARP 2500 began as the Series 2000, made by Alan Pearlman’s company Tonus and renamed the 2500 under the ARP name, according to Wikipedia. It was built from 1970 to 1981. Its most unusual feature was the matrix of sliding switches that replaced patch cords, which let any module’s output be routed to any other module’s input. A museum entry for one of the instruments says the main cabinet offered roughly 9,600 possible connections, and that the matrix was prone to crosstalk.

Wikipedia adds that the switches developed a reputation for dirty connections. The instrument still found devoted users: it says Pete Townshend used one on The Who’s Quadrophenia in 1972, and that Éliane Radigue worked almost exclusively with the 2500 from 1974 to 2000, with her final piece for it winning the 2006 Golden Nica at Ars Electronica according to the museum record.

It was also very expensive. Wikipedia gives a list price between US$7,180 and US$19,920, with larger systems costing up to about $20,000, and says approximately 100 units were sold. The museum record describes Pearlman, a former NASA electrical engineer, as intending the instrument to compete with the first Moog modular systems, and attributes its commercial failure to an unintuitive interface and high production costs. ARP later condensed popular modules from the 2500 into the hardwired ARP 2600.

Williams, Spielberg and the problem of five notes

The film’s central musical device was in the script before the music existed. In a 1997 Total Film interview, which survives in a reposted copy, John Williams says the script called for a five-note motif for the alien spaceship. Wikipedia describes the idea as a kind of mathematical language that scientists could use to communicate with the mothership.

The number five was a deliberate choice. Wikipedia reports that Williams felt four notes would be only a fragment and seven would be a song, so five fell between them. Michael R. W. Dawson, in an excerpt from his book Connectionist Representations of Tonal Music, puts it similarly: the signal had to be long enough to stand apart from simple chords or intervals but not so long that it could stand alone as a melody.

A mathematician’s answer

How many candidates did Williams write? Sources disagree. Wikipedia says more than 300 versions, while the Total Film interview and the Dawson excerpt both say about 350. In the interview, Williams says he still has them at home and has never used them elsewhere.

The more entertaining part is how the choice was made. Williams says he and Spielberg held meetings and played the candidates repeatedly but could not agree on one. They then asked a mathematician friend of Spielberg’s how many five-note combinations exist in the twelve-note chromatic scale, without rhythmic variation. Williams recalls the answer as about 134,000, and says that since they had already reached 350, they stopped there and picked one of them.

I have not independently checked that number, so it should be read as Williams’s recollection. Wikipedia notes that Williams was nominated for an Academy Award for the score in 1978, the year his Star Wars score won, and that at the 1979 Grammys he won Best Instrumental Composition for “Theme from Close Encounters” and Best Album of Original Score.

An installer becomes a musician

The synthesizer in the film was an ARP 2500, and the man who plays it is Philip Dodds, known elsewhere as Phil or Phillip. Wikipedia describes him as ARP’s vice president of engineering. ARP sent him to install the instrument on set, and Spielberg then cast him as Jean Claude, the musician who performs the sequence on the synthesizer.

The casting story has more than one version. Wikipedia’s articles on the ARP 2500 and on Dodds say he was cast after being sent to install the unit. The Dawson excerpt adds a detail: the actor originally meant to play the part fell ill, and Spielberg saw Dodds working on the machine, liked his look and cast him. That account appears in only one source I read, and the excerpt itself does not verify it against others.

Practical details are easier to confirm. Vintage Synth and Synthtopia report that the production used a fully loaded main cabinet, two fully loaded wing cabinets and dual keyboards in a custom case. Wikipedia’s ARP 2500 article adds that the unit used in the film was damaged by artificial fog, though that appears in a single article.

The scene at Devils Tower

In the story, witnesses in Dharamsala, India, report that the UFOs make the five-tone sound. Scientists broadcast the phrase into space and receive numbers back, which turn out to be coordinates for Devils Tower, near Moorcroft, Wyoming. At the climax, according to Wikipedia, the researchers try to communicate with the visitors using light and sound on a large electrical billboard.

According to Dawson, the motif is played on the ARP 2500 in the Devils Tower sequence, and Dodds plays the signal faster and louder as the French scientist, Lacombe, played by François Truffaut, walks out along the runway. The mothership echoes the notes, which Dawson calls an interstellar jam session of increasing tempo and complexity. Wikipedia adds that Lacombe also uses Curwen hand signs that correspond to the five-note phrase, and that the extraterrestrial responds in kind.

What the film did for the ARP 2500

For the ARP 2500, the film was a spectacular cameo and not a rescue. Vintage Synth calls the appearance perhaps the most famous and obvious vintage synthesizer cameo in a movie, and says many viewers know the motif without knowing which instrument played it. The museum entry says only that the five notes “likely” came from the ARP 2500, a reminder that even the identity of the instrument is sometimes treated cautiously.

Wikipedia’s ARP Instruments article records that the company declared bankruptcy in May 1981 after financial trouble linked to the Avatar, another product that sold poorly. The 2500’s own production run ended in the same year. The film’s synthesizer outlived the company’s finances in the public imagination, and the motif is parodied to this day. Vintage Synth notes that Monsters vs. Aliens (2009) has its president play the phrase on what is clearly a Yamaha DX7, not an ARP.

Final perspective

Close Encounters shows how little a famous sound can depend on commercial success. The ARP 2500 sold around a hundred units, had an interface the museum record calls unintuitive, and appeared in the film largely because an engineer was on set to install it. Yet a single scene turned it into the best-known synthesizer in cinema.

The story also shows how film music is made from compromise and choice. Williams wrote hundreds of candidates, and he and a director who could not agree settled the matter by stopping at the number they had reached. The five notes had to be simple enough for humans and aliens to share in a story, and that simplicity is probably why they survive. A phrase that works as a greeting is also a phrase that works as a parody and a memory of 1977.

Related stories

Sources

Bernardo de Azevedo
Written by
Bernardo de AzevedoFounder & Editor

His connection with music began at age 6, in the 1980s, when his father introduced him to Jean-Michel Jarre's Rendez-Vous on vinyl. He works professionally in the legal field, while synthesizers became his space for abstraction and creative exploration. Founder of The Synth Source.